Halloween candy isn’t just for kids—we have a trick up our sleeve to help you elevate your favorites for a grown-up twist. I teamed up with our extraordinary cheese expert, Kim Martin, to find out which cheeses pair best with classic candies.
If the idea of candy and cheese together sends a shiver down your spine, fear not. Kim is a certified sensory evaluator—essentially a cheese sommelier—which makes her more than qualified to share some magical recommendations. As she puts it: “Cheese has many of the same characteristics as Halloween candy. They share flavors and textures—many cheeses have the fudginess of a candy bar. They mimic each other beautifully and work wonderfully together.”
Without further ado, here are Kim’s un-boo-lievable combinations that are destined to take your Halloween party from spooky to spectacular.
Three Musketeers + Beemster Goat Cheese
“The marshmallow fluff with the condensed milk in the cheese is meant to be.” -KM
Why it works: Beemster goat cheese has a tangy sweetness that enhances the soft, sugary flavors of Three Musketeers. It’s a lush, dreamy pairing that will cast a spell over your taste buds.
Candy Corn + Mimolette
“Just look at those bright orange pumpkin colors. It’s a stunning pair!” -KM
Why it works: Candy corn offers a burst of intense sweetness, while Mimolette packs a punch of salt. This sweet-and-salty duo is equally matched in flavor and Halloween-worthy presentation.
Kit Kat + Gorgonzola Dolce Ambrosi
“Kit Kats and blue cheese are my all-time favorite Halloween combo.” -KM
Why it works: Like yin and yang, the creamy richness of blue cheese perfectly complements Kit Kat’s crisp crunch. From a flavor perspective, blue cheese and chocolate share berry undertones. Your guests will be dying to sink their fangs into this one!
Butterfinger + Zola Gouda
“This combo is full of toffee-tastic deliciousness.” -KM
Why it works: Gouda has salty, toffee-like notes that blend effortlessly with the salted caramel taste of Butterfinger. These two enhance each other because of their wicked similarities.
Sour Patch Kids + Humboldt Fog
“Humboldt Fog is so eerie; it’s the perfect counterpoint to bright, smiley Sour Patch Kids.” -KM
Why it works: This duo delivers a pleasant citrusy surprise. Humboldt Fog spreads almost like butter over firm Sour Patch Kids. Both have zesty, fruity flavors that tango in tandem on the tongue.
Nerds + Merlot Bellavitano
“It’s a creamy, crunchy, and zippy pairing. Plus, who doesn’t love wine!” -KM
Why it works: This pairing may raise some eyebrows, but the wine-cured cheese combined with the tartness of Nerds is a truly harmonious blend. It’s a puckery, lively explosion of flavor that lingers long past the midnight hour.
Almond Joy + Parmigiano Reggiano
“Get ready for a tropical fusion that will be the talk of the party.”-KM
Why it works: The coconut in Almond Joys pairs beautifully with the nutty, pineapple notes of Parmigiano Reggiano. (This combo is my personal favorite! I may have gone a little batty loading up my plate.)
M&Ms + Locatelli Pecorino Romano
“This pairing hits all the right notes: sweet, salty, crunchy, and rich.” -KM
Why it works: The heightened saltiness of Pecorino Romano offsets the intense sweetness of M&Ms. It’s a sweet-and-salty coupling as strong as the love between Morticia and Gomez.
Reese’s + Beecher’s Flagship
“Beecher’s Flagship has the same toasted nuttiness that makes Reese’s so special.” -KM
Why it works: This duo is loaded with roasty, toasty goodness. Beecher’s Flagship’s fudge-like consistency makes it an even textural match for Reese’s peanut butter and chocolate.
Tootsie Roll + Metropolitan Market Double Crème Brie
“These two play really nicely together.” -KM
Why it works: It’s a devilishly malty medley! Brie’s creamy consistency and mellow flavor complement the sweetness of Tootsie Rolls without becoming overpowering.
Eat, drink, and be scary!
All of these cheeses can be found haunting our cheese department. Try these pairings for yourself—it might just be the most fun trick or treat you ever have.
Wishing you a frightfully fun and delicious Halloween!